I have a frameless soft top. I really like it. It is about 4 years old now and just this summer had to have some straps reinforced by a canvas shop, but overall its been fine. Winter in totally fine. Same as a factory top (2002 TJ) in terms of sound/warmth. Spring/Summer/Fall very easy to manipulate how i want. Flip just the top over me back for a sunroof, leave the top clasped over me to give shade, or take completely off. I can take it off completely (windows included) in less than 10 minutes. I would get another one if i ever needed to. Here are some pics as i have it now. I have the windows out and door surrounds off, but still have my shade.